Many car buyers cite reliability as the most important consideration in their buying journey. However, not everyone weighs the factors equally. Depending on your situation, you may be most concerned with longevity, durability, safety, consistency, or maintenance costs. 

How reliable is the Subaru Forester? First introduced in 1997, this crossover SUV has earned a well-deserved reputation for providing owners with excellent value through low total ownership costs and a recognized safety record. Over the years, the Forester has grown in size and expanded its configurations from entry-level models to top-of-the-line versions such as the 2025 Forester Wilderness, specially designed for off-roading. Our sales and service experts at John Kennedy Subaru in Plymouth Meeting, Pennsylvania, have gathered information to help you avoid common Forester problems and decide which of these iconic vehicles is right for you.

Historical Reliability

The Subaru Forester offers excellent value to buyers both as a new and used vehicle. Many automotive writers and other experts have offered opinions about the most reliable Subaru Forester model years. Here’s our round-up of some of the leading views on the Subaru Forester’s reliability by generation. 

AutoTrader

Saying that “it’s tough to go wrong with any Subaru Forester,” Autotrader gave high marks to the Subaru Forester for the model years 2020 to 2023. “All three years posted solid scores for reliability and owner satisfaction,” the specialty news publication wrote. Reviewers also identified the Forester models from 2018, 2012, and 2003 as reliable. Autotrader also noted that the Forester has consistently earned Top Pick honors from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.

AutoDNA blog

After examining details on powertrain, fuel efficiency, safety ratings, and other variables across all five generations of Subaru Forester vehicles, the AutoDNA blog identified three periods that offer the highest reliability returns. Their picks in an October 2024 article are:

• 2016 to 2018 model years, known for their “balance of performance, reliability, and modern features”
• 2021 to present model years, highlighted for “advanced safety technologies and comfort”
• 2014 to 2016 model years, featuring a “great combination of safety, efficiency, and capability”

CarBuzz 

After reviewing J.D. Power rankings along with other published Subaru Forester consumer reviews, CarBuzz in 2025 also produced its answer to the question “Are Subaru Foresters reliable?” Noting the popularity of the Forester on the secondary market, CarBuzz wanted to look at model ages, common mechanical issues, and other concerns. Their review spotlighted these generations as the Subaru Forester’s most reliable model years:

• 2009 to 2013: CarBuzz mentioned this generation “based on “glowing owner reviews and few complaints. Third-gen Forester models are among the most enjoyable and reliable to own, which should provide prospective buyers with some peace of mind.” 
• 2019 to 2024: The publication cited the platform’s updated engine with direct fuel injection, which provided greater power, torque, and fuel economy.
• 2014 to 2018: This generation featured new transmissions, interior upgrades, and a more robust, “sports-oriented” suspension.

Comparing the Forester’s Reliability to Competitors

When considering buying a used Forester, you’ll probably encounter similar vehicles from other manufacturers, and you might wonder how the Forester compares. Other options in this class include the Ford Bronco, Chevrolet Equinox, and Toyota RAV4.

Depending on which variable you’re concerned with, the Forester compares favorably to all of these vehicles based on initial reliability estimates in 2025 models from U.S. News & World Report. The 2025 Forester scores 8.6/10 from U.S. News, based on an 83/100 rating in reliability from J.D. Power. The magazine cites the Forester’s “practical and rugged nature.” 

The take on comparable vehicles is as follows:

• Ford Bronco (8.6): Based on a reliability score of 7.7 from J.D. Power, U.S. News hails the Bronco’s off-road performance.
• Chevrolet Equinox (8.5): J.D. Power scores Equinox at 86 for reliability, but U.S. News notes that “performance remains somewhat disappointing.”
• Ford Escape (8.5): Highlighting a model that “lags” the competition, U.S. News reports that the 2025 Escape registers an 85 on the J.D. Power scale.

Let our sales team at John Kennedy Subaru help you sort through the competition for the Forester to find the perfect vehicle match for you.

New vs. Used: Reliability Considerations

When considering car options, you might wonder whether to buy a used Subaru Forester. Here are some reliability variables to think about when debating whether to buy a new or used Forester.

• Maintenance costs: Reliability ratings aside, older model years are likely to come with a higher total cost of maintenance. Used Foresters generally require more frequent repairs, whereas with a new vehicle, you can expect to spend only on routine maintenance.
• Safety considerations: As technology evolves, cars offer new electronic safety features. The Forester will likely come with more relevant safety features and other technology in a new or more recent model year.
• Depreciation: Buying new means shouldering the most significant part of the depreciation curve. Generally speaking, used models with good reliability ratings offer more value to owners in the end.
• Warranty coverage: New Foresters usually have factory warranties that cover unexpected defects or surprise repairs. Used vehicles may have some warranty coverage, but generally, you’re on your own.
• Known versus unknown: Used cars have an established track record of reliability; the newest vehicles have not yet proven themselves.

Is a Subaru Forester the Right Choice for You?

While longevity isn’t a guarantee of reliability, it certainly is an important indicator. The Subaru Forester has a proud track record of providing value over the years. The best way to determine if it’s right for you is to take one for a test drive. Our John Kennedy Subaru team in Plymouth Meeting, Pennsylvania, is ready to answer your questions about Subaru and its reliability. We’re a full-service dealership near Philadelphia that sells new and used cars and offers high-quality maintenance and repair support. Call or contact us today for a test-drive and a consultation.

Posted in Reliability, Subaru Forester | No Comments »